How to Deal With Negative and Fake Reviews on Amazon

ByGulfam Haidar

Sellers cannot delete reviews. To deal with fake negative reviews on Amazon, report each one that breaks Amazon’s rules, with evidence. If Amazon agrees, it takes the review down. For an honest bad review, fix the cause and message the buyer to help, without asking them to change it. Under a US rule in force since 21 October 2024, buying or hiding reviews can cost up to $53,088 per violation.

Key facts

  • The FTC final rule on fake reviews was announced on 14 August 2024 and took effect on 21 October 2024 (FTC).
  • The top civil penalty is $53,088 per violation after the 2025 inflation adjustment, up from $51,744 (FTC).
  • Amazon says it blocked “hundreds of millions of suspected fake reviews” in 2025 before shoppers saw them (Amazon).
  • Amazon shut down more than 100 websites tied to review fraud and scams in 2025 (Amazon).
  • Sellers cannot remove product reviews themselves, and Amazon bans incentivized reviews (Amazon).

Product reviews vs seller feedback: which one are you dealing with?

First, check which kind of rating you got, since each one has its own route. A product review rates the item. Seller feedback rates you as a seller: shipping, packing and service.

Many removal pages mix the two up. That sends sellers to the wrong form, and weeks go by.

Product review Seller feedback
What it rates The product itself The seller’s service on one order
Where it shows The product detail page, for every seller of that item Your seller profile page
Who can leave one Shoppers under Amazon’s Community Guidelines The buyer on that order
Can the seller remove it? No. Only Amazon can, if it breaks the rules No. Amazon can remove it if it breaks feedback rules
How to ask “Report” link on the review, or Report a Violation in Brand Registry Feedback Manager in Seller Central
Affects Star rating, conversion, the “Customers say” summary Account health metrics and seller rating

If a buyer reviews the product inside seller feedback, you can usually ask Amazon to remove it. The rest of this guide covers product reviews, since that is where fake negative reviews do the most damage.

Can you remove negative reviews on Amazon?

No. A seller cannot delete, hide or edit any product review. Amazon states this plainly on its trustworthy reviews page.

Here is what you can and cannot do.

You can You cannot
Report a review that breaks Amazon’s rules Delete or hide a review yourself
Send Amazon evidence of a coordinated attack Ask a buyer to change or remove a review
Message a buyer to fix a problem with the order Offer a refund, gift or discount for a new review
Fix the product, listing or packaging Reply in public under the review (Amazon ended public comments in 2020, per seller consultancies)
Ask every buyer for a review through Amazon’s tools Pay a service that pushes buyers to take reviews down

A “review removal” service that promises results sells something only Amazon controls. At best, it files the same reports you can file for free. At worst, it pressures buyers, and that risk lands on your brand.

How to report fake Amazon reviews: every route

You have three routes, and a serious case often uses all three. Pick based on how many reviews you face and whether you own the brand.

Route 1: the “Report” link on the review. This works for one review at a time. Anyone can use it, including sellers who do not own the brand.

  1. Open the product page and scroll to the review.
  2. Click “Report” under the review text.
  3. Pick the reason that fits best and submit.

This route gives you no box for proof. Use it for obvious cases, like a review about the wrong product.

Route 2: Report a Violation (RAV) in Brand Registry. Brand Registry is Amazon’s free program for trademark owners. It gives you the RAV tool, which has a reviews option. See our Amazon Brand Registry guide if you have not enrolled.

  1. In Brand Registry, open Report a Violation.
  2. Choose the reviews option and search your ASIN (Amazon’s product ID).
  3. Select each review you are reporting.
  4. Write a short, factual note and attach your evidence pack.

The same tool handles counterfeit reports, which we cover in our guide to reporting counterfeits on Amazon.

Route 3: Seller Support or Account Health. Use this when many reviews land at once. It also fits when an attack comes with other abuse, like fake complaints. Open a case, name the ASIN, list the review IDs and attach the same proof. Keep each case number in your log.

What breaks Amazon’s review rules

Amazon removes a review only when it breaks the Community Guidelines. So your report must name the rule. “This review is unfair” will not work. “This review is about a different product” might.

Report reviews that show one of these signs:

  • Conflict of interest. Written by a competitor, the seller, family, staff or a paid reviewer.
  • Off-topic content. The review is about shipping speed, price or the seller, not the product. That belongs in seller feedback.
  • Wrong product. It describes an item you do not sell.
  • Personal or hateful content. It includes contact details, links, ads or abusive language.
  • Manipulation. It is part of a group of reviews posted to push a rating up or down.

A 1-star review that says “broke after two weeks” breaks none of these rules. Amazon will keep it, and you should treat it as honest feedback.

Evidence pack for a review attack

A strong report shows a pattern, and a weak one shows a feeling. Amazon’s teams see a huge number of reports, so make yours quick to check.

In the accounts we manage, we build one sheet per attack before filing anything. Here is the template.

Field What to record Why it matters
Review ID and link The URL of each review Lets Amazon find it fast
Date and time When each review posted Clusters in a few hours point to a planned attack
Star rating 1 to 5 Sudden runs of 1-star reviews stand out
Verified Purchase Yes or no Unverified reviews in a burst look suspect
Reviewer profile Review count, other products reviewed Profiles that only review rivals or only post 1-star
Wording match Repeated phrases across reviews Copy-paste text shows one author
Order match Whether an order exists in your records No order for a “Verified” claim is worth noting
Normal velocity Your usual reviews per week Shows how far the spike sits from normal

Add a short summary on top. For example: “Between 3 and 5 May, 14 one-star reviews posted on ASIN B0XXXXXXX. Our normal rate is about 3 reviews a week. Nine share the phrase ‘cheap plastic smell.'” Plain numbers like these beat long stories every time.

How to handle an honest negative review

Most bad reviews are real, so treat them as free research. Fix the cause first, then help the buyer, and never ask for a changed rating.

Step 1: find the pattern. Read your last 30 critical reviews and tag each by theme: size, smell, breakage, missing parts. Then check the “Customers say” block on your product page. Amazon uses generative AI to write this summary from reviews (Amazon). If a complaint shows up there, shoppers see it before they read a single review.

Step 2: fix the root cause. Change the product, the box, or the listing. Often the listing is the real problem. If buyers say “smaller than expected,” add the size in inches to the title, the images and the first bullet.

Step 3: help the buyer through Buyer-Seller Messaging. This is Amazon’s inbox for notes tied to an order. Keep the note about the order problem only. A compliant example:

> Hi, this is the support team for [Brand]. We saw that your order of [product] arrived with a cracked lid. We are sorry about that. We can send a free replacement lid or a full refund, whichever you prefer. Just reply here and we will sort it out today.

Notice what is missing. No mention of the review, no request to edit it, and no offer tied to the rating. The refund exists to fix the order, not to buy a new review. If the buyer updates the review on their own, that is their choice.

Here is some math on why the fix beats the fight. Say a product has 200 reviews at 4.6 stars, which is 920 total stars. Twelve new 1-star reviews bring it to 932 stars over 212 reviews, or 4.40. Getting back to 4.6 needs about 108 new 5-star reviews. The math: (932 + 5x) ÷ (212 + x) = 4.6, so x = 108. Amazon does not use a simple average, so treat this as a rough guide. The point stands: stopping new complaints costs far less than outrunning them.

What not to do: the FTC rule and Amazon policy

The FTC Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule bans several review tactics in the US. It took effect on 21 October 2024, and each violation can cost up to $53,088 (FTC). This section is general information, not legal advice. Talk to a lawyer about your own case.

Action Rule it breaks Risk
Posting fake or AI-written reviews FTC rule, Amazon policy Up to $53,088 per violation; listing or account action
Paying or gifting for positive reviews FTC rule (incentives tied to sentiment), Amazon policy Fines, review removal, account suspension
Offering a refund if the buyer removes a review Amazon policy; can count as review suppression Account action; FTC exposure
Threats, legal letters or false claims to kill a review FTC rule (review suppression) Up to $53,088 per violation
Staff or family reviews without disclosure FTC rule (insider reviews) Fines, review removal
Hiring a “removal” service that pressures buyers FTC rule and Amazon policy, through your agent Liability sits with your brand
Asking only happy buyers for reviews Not banned by the rule, but the FTC says it “could violate the FTC Act” Legal risk; also breaks Amazon policy

The FTC announced the rule on 14 August 2024 after a 5 to 0 vote. It also bans company-run “independent” review sites and fake social media numbers. The FTC’s rule Q&A gives plain examples.

Some guides still suggest cease and desist letters to reviewers. Be careful here, because a threat meant to make an honest buyer pull a review is the review suppression the rule bans.

How to get more genuine reviews, the compliant way

The best defense against a few bad reviews is a steady flow of real ones. Amazon gives you three safe tools.

Request a Review button. In Seller Central, open the order and click “Request a Review.” Amazon then sends a stock message. Third-party guides such as Web Retailer report that it works 5 to 30 days after delivery, once per order. It asks for both a product review and seller feedback. Since you cannot edit the text, you cannot slant it. Many sellers send it for every order. That also keeps you clear of the “only happy buyers” problem.

Amazon Vine. Vine sends free units to trusted reviewers that Amazon picks. You cannot choose the reviewers or the rating. Third-party sources report fees per parent ASIN by units enrolled. They list $0 for 1 to 2 units, $75 for 3 to 10, and $200 for 11 to 30. They also say Amazon bills only when a review posts. Check the current terms in Seller Central before you enroll.

Worked math on Vine: at the reported $200 tier, 30 reviewed units cost about $6.67 per review in fees. Add the cost of the units themselves. For a new launch, see our Amazon product launch guide.

Product inserts. A card in the box can thank the buyer, explain setup, and give a support email. Keep it neutral, and do not ask for a 5-star review or offer a gift for one. Do not ask unhappy buyers to email you instead of reviewing.

What Amazon does about fake reviews

Amazon catches most fake reviews before anyone sees them. In its 2025 report, Amazon says it “proactively blocked hundreds of millions of suspected fake reviews” (Amazon).

It also shut down more than 100 websites tied to review fraud and scams in 2025. Press reports add that legal action has stopped more than 40 review brokers. Amazon checks reviews, and the accounts behind them, with machine learning.

For you, this has two sides. Fake positive reviews rarely last, so buying them wastes money. And fake negative reviews that slip through need a clear report from you, because the filters did not catch them.

How a shopper deletes their own Amazon review

Only the person who wrote a review can delete it. If you are a shopper who wants to remove your own review, follow these steps on desktop:

  1. Go to Account & Lists, then Your Account.
  2. Open your Amazon profile and find the reviews tab.
  3. Find the review and choose Delete (or Edit to change it).

The review disappears from the product page soon after. Sellers should never send buyers these steps unless the buyer asks.

When bad reviews point to a product problem

Sometimes the reviews are right, and no report will fix that. Watch for the same complaint in several reviews over a few months. If the “Customers say” summary names the same flaw, shoppers already see it.

In that case, stop reporting and start fixing. Talk to your maker, change the spec, and update the listing. A new version may need a new listing, but check Amazon’s rules on variations and condition first.

This advice may not fit a few cases. If your product is under a safety review, talk to Amazon and a lawyer first. And if an attack ties to hijackers on your listing, treat it as a brand protection case through Brand Registry.

If review work eats your week, our Amazon account management service covers reports, listing fixes and a compliant review flow in one plan.

Frequently asked questions

Can sellers remove negative reviews on Amazon?

No, sellers cannot remove any product review. Only Amazon can, and only when a review breaks its Community Guidelines. You can report rule-breaking reviews with proof and fix the cause of honest complaints. You can also help buyers through Buyer-Seller Messaging, without mentioning the review. Any service that promises removal cannot deliver more than that.

How do I report a fake review on Amazon?

Click “Report” under the review for single cases. Brand owners should use Report a Violation in Brand Registry and pick the reviews option. It lets you add notes and proof. For a large wave, also open a Seller Support or Account Health case. List review IDs, dates and wording matches.

How long does Amazon take to remove a reported review?

Amazon does not publish a timeline for review reports. In practice, some reports get a quick answer and others take much longer or get no change at all. Keep every case number and the date you filed, and add new proof to the same case instead of filing duplicates.

Can a competitor leave fake negative reviews?

Yes, it happens, and it breaks Amazon’s rules on conflicts of interest. Look for clusters of 1-star reviews within hours, repeated phrases, and reviewer profiles that only praise rivals. Put those facts in an evidence pack and report through Brand Registry. Do not accuse anyone in public or contact the reviewer.

Can I contact a buyer who left a bad review?

Yes, through Buyer-Seller Messaging, but only about their order. You may offer a replacement, refund or setup help to solve the problem. You may not ask them to change or remove the review, or tie any offer to it. That breaks Amazon policy and can count as review suppression under FTC rules.

Can I reply publicly to an Amazon review?

No, not on regular product reviews. Seller consultancies report that Amazon removed public comments on reviews in 2020. Fix the issue in private through Buyer-Seller Messaging instead. Then update the listing so future buyers get the right facts. The listing is the part of the page you control.

What is the difference between seller feedback and product reviews?

Seller feedback rates your service on one order, such as shipping and packing, and appears on your seller profile. Product reviews rate the item and appear on the product page for every seller. They use separate reporting routes: Feedback Manager for feedback, and the Report link or Brand Registry for reviews.

No. Paying, refunding or pressuring buyers to remove honest reviews counts as review suppression. The FTC rule on this took effect on 21 October 2024. Fines reach $53,088 per violation. Hiring an agency to do it does not protect you. This is general information, not legal advice, so check with a lawyer.

How does Amazon Vine work, and what does it cost?

Amazon sends free units to reviewers it picks, and they post honest reviews marked as Vine. You cannot choose reviewers or ratings. Third-party sources report fees of $0, $75 or $200 per parent ASIN by units enrolled, billed only when reviews post. Confirm the current fees in Seller Central.

When can I use the Request a Review button?

Third-party guides report a window of 5 to 30 days after delivery, and one request per order. The button sits on the order page in Seller Central. Amazon writes and sends the message, which asks for a product review and seller feedback. That keeps it compliant by design.

How does Amazon detect fake reviews?

Amazon uses machine learning plus human teams to check reviews and the accounts that post them. It says it blocked hundreds of millions of suspected fake reviews in 2025 before shoppers saw them. It also sues review brokers and shut down more than 100 fraud websites that year.

Sources

Similar Posts